Yesterday, the first of the bake-off entries was finally judged by this here Cookie Queen and her beloved Grizzled. Lamblets partook in the tastings, but their findings will not be entered into the final analysis. They are not yet 18 and could skew the results with unfettered minds, no preconceived ideas...
Let us begin!
First of all, kudos go out to Mandos for superior packing or plain old luck. His shipment arrived (FIRST!!!) in a box that as Grizzled said, looked like it had been shipped at the bottom of the airfreight container. Even the lovely snowflake tin was semi-smooshed, but his goods were in fine shape.
Mandos submitted 3 bake-off items. The oft seen brownie, with separately packed frosting, an Asian brittle (AG, I know you said this is not a baked item, but give it a chance, give it a try. Plus, were you not open to ethnic variations and interpretations???) and some mysterious treat entitled, "Egg Sweet".
We open, we sniffed, we nibbled. We tried the brownie. It was a fine brownie. Nothing I'd write home about, but a solid brownie. I think I was almost more in love with the frosting which seemed to have bits of nuts in it and had a delicate almond aftertaste.
Grizzled LOVED the brownies, he being a fan of the leathery brownie, none of this springy cake-like stuff for him. He liked the fact that they had a strong cocoa flavor and were not too sweet. He preferred them without the frosting and was glad he had a choice.
Next we move on to the Asian Brittle. Oh my. I like a little brittle, but generally a little goes a long way. There are usually too few nuts and too much candy coating. Not in this case. Mandos made a truly stellar and complex brittle. It was bursting with cashews and almonds. To the best of my knowledge it also had sesame seeds, sesame sticks and some sort of freeze-dried or fried pea. Drizzled over this combination was a lovely brittle coating, but not too much. It was just the right amount to give the other ingredients a little sweetness and added crunch. The best part however, was the occasional bursts of hot chili. At least that's what I think it was. Every once in awhile you'd get this gentle buzz of heat spreading over your tongue, cutting the sweetness of the brittle and blending oh so nicely with the nuts. If anything, Grizzled and I thought it could have used more. The heat with the sweet and other ingredients was truly a delicious mix.
Last, but not least we tried Mandos' Egg Sweet. This is supposedly a top secret family dish that was guarded by his mother. While Mandos originally described it as custardy, it really falls somewhere between a really moist macaroon and a lemon square in texture. It was delicious. Again, surprisingly not too sweet even though Mandos swore there was enough sugar to blow off the heads of bland Americans. Maybe I'm not as bland as I thought. :)
The Egg Sweet's flavor is predominantly almond, a subtle, delicate almond that worked well with the eggy accompaniment. I am guessing that the texture and flavor of the treat were due to using ground almonds as a flour of sorts. And as if that weren't enough, each little morsel was topped with its own individual almond.
Mandos scored well with the western judges. He backed up his talk with solid entries... what AG and UC have to say, we'll have to wait and see!
I'll be posting according to the order in which we receive the entries. Next up... CLAIRE!!!
I also received the Team Mandos entry yesterday and was quick to sample the goods. While I was not particularly taken in by the brownie combination, I have nothing but raves for the brittle. The spiciness that Jennifer alluded to was because of the wasabi-coated peas - an excellent and I almost wonder integral component of the brittle. What won me over even more was the honey sesame stick. I cannot get enough of the those. The brittle was crunchy, sufficiently sweet, and texturally-diverse. While not a traditional bake-off item, the punch it packed is going to score Mandos highly in some categories. The egg sweet is an interesting concoction. The almond flavour is prominent - almost to the point where it had pistachio overtones. The egg sweet reminds me of marzipan- and it is substantial. I don't think it is too sweet by any means, but the denseness of the dessert needs proper respect. I think it needs to be consumed in combination with something else. I will try ice cream, but if Mandos has any suggestions, I am open. Perhaps a fruity sorbet would be better.
Actually if any judges have requests on accompanying food/beverage for maximal enjoyment of their desserts, it would be very helpful. For example, Claire had perfect beverages to accompany her cookies, and I must say that they were essential. So please, whether it be coffee, tea, milk, ice cream, whipped cream, or grapefruit, I will comply for the good of the food.
Posted by: The Uncanny Canadian | December 18, 2007 at 09:03 AM
UC- That was it! I knew I had had those peas before, but was having a brain cramp. Yes, wasabi coated peas. Didn't you want more? I did. I wanted more heat.
And you're right, marzipan is an excellent description of the egg sweet. Although, not as pasty in my mind, very on the mark flavor-wise and density-wise.
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 09:16 AM
The brittle involved baking and/or a wheat product. It did! (Though not necessarily in that order.)
Hmm, I never thought of an accompaniment for the egg sweet. I think the correct accompaniment is probably another South Asian-flavoured food, like kulfi (a kind of pistachio ice cream) or shir qurma (chilled noodles in sweet almond sauce). I guess if you could find a pistachio ice cream, it might be the right thing. But failing that, I guess mango juice might be the right thing to drink with it? As for the entire meal, I've only ever eaten it after spicy food, particularly foods like biriyani. But any spicy rice dish, I think, goes best with it.
There was ginger and chili in the brittle, as well as wasabi peas. I'd have put more but I only have a small window in which the sugar is melty enough, and I was also not sure of the hotness levels the judges take.
Posted by: Mandos | December 18, 2007 at 09:32 AM
I take it hot, Mandos. Really hot!!!!!
Posted by: The Uncanny Canadian | December 18, 2007 at 09:43 AM
Mandos- Your taking heat-tolerance levels into consideration was very thoughtful. The brittle was great just as it was. I'd be curious to try it with more heat though.
I can see how the egg sweet would be great after very spicy food. It was a really delicate flavor. Quite good.
Now I'm curious about the chilled noodles with sweet almond sauce!!
Again- great entry!
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 09:43 AM
Ahhh, I forfeit.
I'm gonna save the postage and eat my own cookies.
I'll be over here in the corner by myself.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 09:57 AM
BP! You may NOT forfeit! Once you're in, you're in! Besides, even Snag entered and he doesn't have one spare moment these days.
You must finished what you started...
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 10:35 AM
Oh, the baking is done.
The cookies are delish. I placed them in a lockbox, or we would have suffered a Chuckles-style Cookie Monster meltdown also.
I am waiting on Zelmo; as usual, he is a no-show.
But how does one compete with the Ineffable Mandos and/or The Glue Birl Production and Exposition Mega-Corporation? Or Claire and her Beverages?
Maybe if I include a note stating that the cookies are best accompanied by ganja. They'll be the best cookies you ever tasted!!
Or maybe just some tequila. That's it! My cookies are best tasted by dunking in tequila!! And wash 'em down with tequila.
Sigh.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 10:54 AM
BP- just add in that Gehry addition for my house and you're in like Flynn. :)
I'm sure your cookies will more than hold their own (tequilla...). In the words of Ray Stevens, everything is beautiful, in its own way. The same thing goes for a cookie. But an addition wouldn't hurt... Just sayin'...
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 11:16 AM
I recommend bourbon with my entry. A lot of it. Preferably beforehand.
Posted by: Snag | December 18, 2007 at 11:53 AM
Billy, last year I entered with just snickerdoodles. Mainly because Res and BG came to my blog and badgered me. (I tease, I tease).
But in all seriousness, I'm sure this year's judges (like last year's) will appreciate the effort. It's enthusiasm, not quantity that counts.
Posted by: Shayera | December 18, 2007 at 12:03 PM
Shayera is sweet, but it's actually bribes, not enthusiasm nor quantity, that counts. Preferably bribes of the kind that you would count ....
Posted by: The Uncanny Canadian | December 18, 2007 at 12:18 PM
Snag... I thought you recommended lighter fluid.
Shayera- you're right
UC- you're also right...
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 12:41 PM
Billy, are you saying it's over? Nothing is over until we decide it is! Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor? No!
Posted by: Brando | December 18, 2007 at 01:05 PM
UC, I promise to bake you cookies next week after I finish moving and unpacking. And if you're lucky, they'll be the macaroons I made for Res this Summer.
Posted by: Shayera | December 18, 2007 at 01:06 PM
I would like to suggest that BP is perfectly correct in his desire to yield to me. And everyone who follows his lead decreases the delay after which I might receive my well-deserved Cookie Crown.
Posted by: Mandos | December 18, 2007 at 01:07 PM
OK, UC, consider the bagfull of marbles included!!
My only hope is the pity vote, and since AG and jennifer are pitiless, I can get at most a little sympathy votage from UC and Grizzled.... it won't be enough.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 01:08 PM
I don't yield to YOU, Mandos.
I yield to your obviously highly effective bribage of the judgorama.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 01:09 PM
Now Billy's going to send a large death cookie that says, "Eat Me!"
I have plenty of pity, BP... plenty of empathy, just not a lot for ewe.
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 01:10 PM
ouch.
Now I REALLY need to eat all those cookies.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 03:30 PM
I have infinite compassion and kindness for anybody that bakes me cookies or otherwise. If you're looking for redemption from your earthly sins, I can arrange that as well.
Posted by: The Uncanny Canadian | December 18, 2007 at 03:55 PM
UC- kissin' up! :)
BP- since AG's not here... stop yer whinin' and ship those cookies! Besides, this is the glory of Mandos thread!
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 04:04 PM
I am snark-free. And jealous. Nice job, Mandos!
Posted by: Kathleen | December 18, 2007 at 04:36 PM
Alright Kathleen! Raising this thread to a higher level.
I hope all is safe in your area and that your lungs recover.
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 04:56 PM
Man, Mandos. I can't wait to win, because I want you sending me some brittle next year! :)
Posted by: Claire | December 18, 2007 at 05:02 PM
That's what I love about Canadians. They're so clueless about corruption and bribery, UC is DOING IT THE WRONG DIRECTION!!
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 05:03 PM
You'd think so, but as recent events in Canada are showing, Mulroney sure knew the right direction.
Posted by: Mandos | December 18, 2007 at 07:47 PM
Bad news for all bake-off contestants. I just received the package from TLB and Brando, and they may have clinched the bribe-off. All I have to say is woweewowowowow!!! Cookies are something else as well, but there will be more about those later. As for the bribes, all I have to say is y'all been served, and it might be worth stepping-up your efforts a notch or fourteen.
Posted by: The Uncanny Canadian | December 18, 2007 at 08:56 PM
UC- I wonder if you got what we got...
Posted by: Jennifer | December 18, 2007 at 09:03 PM
Ah.
Naked pictures of Brando.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 18, 2007 at 09:36 PM
Huh. Baubles will surely wear off. Almonds and sincerity will win the day.
Posted by: Mandos | December 18, 2007 at 11:13 PM
More likely a promise not to send naked pictures of Brando.
Posted by: Snag | December 18, 2007 at 11:33 PM
Jennifer, yes, we gave both sets of judges the same bribes. We are fair and balanced cheaters.
Billy, I don't do full frontal unless I'm getting bribed.
Posted by: Brando | December 19, 2007 at 09:29 AM
I canNOT believe that this pure and wholesome bake-off has degraded to the point where people are discussing full frontal. It's a sad, sad day in cookieland. We're supposed to be baking cookies, not seeing someone's cookies...
I suggest you all take a moment to go sit and reflect on the true meaning of the bake-off...
BRIBES!
Posted by: Jennifer | December 19, 2007 at 09:51 AM
jennifer would prefer we talk about full frontal cookies.
Posted by: Kathleen | December 19, 2007 at 02:07 PM
You're fortunate Chuckles didn't make his in 3-d.
You'd put your eye out.
Posted by: billy pilgrim | December 19, 2007 at 02:17 PM
He did Jennifer. E-mail AG your digits again and he can call you tonight.
We can totally call ya!
We so get to meet the Queen.
Posted by: Adorable Girlfriend | December 19, 2007 at 03:39 PM